Traditional vs Water-Fed Pole: Which Is Better?
Written by Alex, Owner of OutWash
Published
Two methods, the same aim
If you've ever hired a window cleaner, or you're thinking about it, you may have noticed that they don't all work the same way. There are two main methods, and both leave you with clean windows.
Traditional window cleaning is the "old school" way. The window cleaner uses a ladder, washes your windows with a soapy solution on an applicator, then pulls a squeegee across the glass to leave it clear and streak-free.
Water-fed pole cleaning is more popular with window cleaners today. A long, telescopic pole lets them clean your windows safely from the ground, so there's no need for a ladder. A brush on the end of the pole sprays water onto the glass and frames as it scrubs. The water isn't ordinary tap water. It has been purified to remove all the minerals, which are the things that leave spots and marks on glass when the water dries.
So which one is better? Let's look at how each works, where each shines, and where each has its limits.
A brief history of window cleaning
Traditional window cleaning really took off in the 1930s, when a well-known window cleaning brand started making squeegees designed specifically for professionals. For a long time, it was the only way to do the job.
Water-fed poles came along around the 1950s, but those early versions were basic and didn't use purified water. The modern version arrived in the late 1990s, when the company Ionic Systems showed off its Reach and Wash system at the NEC Cleaning Show in 1997. Since then, the method has become a regular sight on streets across the country.
How traditional window cleaning works
The window cleaner starts by applying a cleaning solution to the glass with an applicator, usually a little washing-up liquid mixed with water. They give the window a good scrub, then use a squeegee to wipe away the soapy water and the dirt in one clean sweep. Finally, they wipe the frames with a cloth so nothing drips back onto your freshly cleaned glass.
The big advantage is that the results are instant. Your windows are dry and sparkling the moment the cleaner has finished.
The main limitation is access. Ladders aren't always a safe option, particularly for high windows, uneven ground, or windows that are hard to get to.
How water-fed pole cleaning works
The easiest way to think about it is rinsing rather than wiping.
- What purified water means. Ordinary tap water contains tiny amounts of minerals. You can't see them in the glass, but when a drop of tap water dries, those minerals are left behind as white spots. Purified water has had the minerals filtered out. Without them, there's nothing left to leave a mark.
- How the clean happens. The cleaner uses a soft brush on the end of the pole to loosen the dirt while the water flows through it. Then the windows are rinsed with more purified water, which carries the dirt away. The glass is left to dry naturally, and because the water is pure, it dries without spots or streaks.
- Why it's different from tap water. If you washed your windows at home with a hose or a bucket of tap water and left them to dry, you'd end up with spotty, marked glass. It's the purification that makes this method work.
The advantages
- Reaching upstairs windows from the ground. For suitable windows, the cleaner can stay on the ground rather than climbing a ladder.
- Better access. The pole can reach over some obstacles, such as conservatory roofs, garden furniture or flower beds, where a ladder wouldn't be practical.
- Frames and sills cleaned too. The brush and rinse wash the frames and sills along with the glass, not just the glass itself.
The limitations
- Water quality matters. The method only works if the water is properly purified. If the filters aren't kept up to scratch, spots can appear.
- Technique matters. A good rinse and a thorough scrub make all the difference, and it takes practice to get right.
- Visibility. Because the cleaner is working from a distance, it's a little harder to spot small marks or missed areas than when you're up close.
- Some windows aren't suitable. Older or deteriorated windows, with failing seals or crumbling putty, may not cope well with lots of water.
What about safety?
One of the biggest benefits of the water-fed pole is that it reduces the amount of work done at height. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) advises avoiding work at height where it's reasonably practicable to do so, and a pole is one way of doing that. That said, no method is completely risk-free. Poles can still be hazardous near overhead power lines, for example, and a careful, trained cleaner is important whichever method they use.
Why some customers prefer traditional window cleaning
If you prefer the traditional method, you're far from alone, and there are good reasons for it.
- Familiarity and trust. If you've had your windows cleaned the same way for years, you know what to expect.
- Seeing the result straight away. With a squeegee, the windows are dry and clear as soon as the cleaner steps away.
- A bad experience in the past. Some people have had spotty windows or missed dirt from a water-fed pole clean, and it has put them off.
- Worries about water. Some customers are concerned about brushes touching the glass, water getting into the house through vents or old seals, or windows being left wet.
These preferences are completely fair. Some of them are real problems, such as spots caused by poorly purified water or old windows that can't cope with lots of water. Others are more misunderstandings, such as the idea that wet windows are somehow dirty. Windows left to air dry after a pure-water rinse are usually just as clean as squeegeed ones, they simply take a little while to finish drying.
Common water-fed pole problems and how a good cleaner deals with them
Here are the issues people mention most, and what a good window cleaner does about them.
- Spots or marks left on the glass. This is nearly always down to water that isn't pure enough, or glass that wasn't rinsed properly. A good cleaner checks their water quality regularly, changes their filters on time, and rinses thoroughly from the top of the window down.
- Dirt that doesn't come off. Bird droppings, tree sap and built-up grime sometimes need extra attention. A good cleaner will give those areas an extra scrub with the brush, or finish them by hand if needed.
- Water running down the frames or onto the sills. Some drips are normal, but they shouldn't be a mess. A good cleaner controls how much water they use and takes care around frames and sills.
- Water getting inside. This can happen with worn seals, loose vents or older windows. A good cleaner will spot these in advance, avoid blasting water at weak areas, and tell you if a window isn't suitable for pole cleaning.
- Not seeing what's been missed. Experienced cleaners learn to check their work as they go, looking at the glass from different angles. Many will also check the finished windows again once they're dry.
- Unsuitable windows. Not every window is right for every method. Old wooden frames, damaged seals and windows in poor condition may be better cleaned the traditional way. A good cleaner will be honest with you about that, rather than using one method for everything.
So, which one is better?
The honest answer is that neither is better in every situation. They're two good ways of getting the same result, and each suits different windows.
- Traditional cleaning is brilliant for instant, dry, sparkling results and for windows in good reach of the ground.
- Water-fed pole cleaning is brilliant for higher windows, awkward access and frames that need cleaning alongside the glass.
The best window cleaners are happy to use the right method for the job, and they'll explain why. If you have a preference, just tell us. And if you're not sure, ask! We're always happy to talk through the options.
Thinking of getting your windows cleaned?
Whichever method suits your home, regular cleaning is the easiest way to keep your windows looking their best. We offer a regular clean on a 6 weekly round, so you don't have to think about it. Get in touch for a free, no-obligation quote.
We use a water-fed pole system with purified water, so we can clean your glass, frames and sills safely from the ground. If you're not sure whether it's right for your windows, just ask and we'll talk it through.
